ABSTRACT: ExtrAgility offers a comprehensive approach to modern marketing, driving it towards a more responsible and trustworthy future. By integrating these principles into agile marketing practices, businesses can rebuild trust, contribute positively to society, and ensure sustainable growth. ExtrAgility not only enhances marketing effectiveness but also aligns it with the broader goals of societal and environmental well-being.
ExtrAgility – A Framework for Responsible Modern Marketing
In today’s rapidly evolving marketing landscape, the fusion of technology and creativity has ushered in what many call modern marketing. However, despite these advancements, modern marketing still harbors many of the deceptive practices from the past. This article explores the concept of ExtrAgility, a framework designed to integrate responsible marketing practices into the agile methodology, thereby ensuring that marketing evolves not just technologically but also ethically and responsibly.
The Persistent Issues in Modern Marketing
Modern marketing, though seemingly advanced, often mirrors the deceptive practices of the past. A notable historical example is the deceptive “red-striped” bacon wrapper from the 1950s, which misled consumers into believing the product contained more meat than it actually did. Fast forward to today, and we see similar issues with planned obsolescence, where products are deliberately designed to have a limited lifespan to encourage repeat purchases.
Trust in Marketing is Eroding
Despite the adoption of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) criteria by many multinational corporations, trust in marketing continues to decline. Edelman Trust Barometer found that only forty-two percent of consumers trust businesses to do what is right. Surveys reveal that 80% of CEOs do not trust their communications directors, and only 1% of executives believe that Chief Marketing Officers (CMOs) manage digital transformation effectively. This lack of trust highlights a significant gap between the potential for marketing to drive responsible transformation and its current state.
The Rise of ESG and Responsible Marketing
ESG criteria have become a benchmark for responsible business practices. Leading investors like Blackrock and Vanguard have demonstrated that profitability can coexist with a responsible approach to business. For example, Forbes recently listed several top-performing ESG funds, including the Vanguard FTSE Social Index Fund and the iShares MSCI USA ESG Select ETF.
The Need for Marketing Transformation
Marketing, traditionally focused on profit maximization, must now incorporate principles of responsibility and trust. This transformation is crucial not only for rebuilding trust but also for ensuring long-term sustainability. Marketing must move beyond short-term gains and focus on creating value for all stakeholders, including society and the environment.
Introducing ExtrAgility
ExtrAgility is a concept that extends agile marketing principles to include corporate social responsibility (CSR), ESG criteria, and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). It emphasizes the role of every employee in facilitating governance and responsible practices, ensuring that these values are embedded at every level of the organization.
The Four Pillars of ExtrAgility: Transparency, Authenticity, Empathy, and Sustainability
ExtrAgility integrates several key principles into the agile marketing framework, structured around four fundamental pillars:
- Transparency: Understanding and addressing the regulatory environment and the external impacts of marketing activities. Transparency ensures that all marketing practices are open and honest, fostering trust among consumers and stakeholders.
- Authenticity: Considering the broader political and economic context and ensuring ethical practices in marketing. Authenticity requires marketers to be genuine in their messaging and actions, aligning their brand values with their marketing practices.
- Empathy: Focusing on creating value for society, particularly for the underserved segments. Empathy involves understanding and addressing the needs and concerns of consumers, especially those at the bottom of the pyramid, ensuring that marketing efforts contribute positively to their lives.
- Sustainability: Promoting sustainable practices that contribute to the circular economy and mitigate climate change. Sustainability ensures that marketing practices are environmentally friendly and support long-term ecological balance.
Principles of ExtrAgility
ExtrAgility integrates these four pillars into the agile marketing framework through several key principles:
- Market Regulation and Externalities: Ensuring marketing activities comply with regulations and account for their broader impacts.
- Political Economy and Ethical Marketing: Incorporating ethical considerations and understanding the economic context.
- Social Marketing and Bottom of the Pyramid: Creating value for society, especially underserved communities.
- Circular Economy and Climate Change: Adopting sustainable practices that support environmental goals.
- Cult and Influencer Marketing, Disinformation, and Social Fractures: Addressing the ethical challenges of modern marketing practices.
- Happiness and Well-being: Ensuring marketing practices contribute to the well-being of consumers and society.
Integrating Responsible Marketing into Agile Practices
To effectively integrate responsible marketing into agile practices, it’s essential to codify these principles and develop practical exercises that promote responsible behavior.
Practical Exercises for Promoting Responsibility
Case 1: Individuals and Interactions Over Processes and Tools
Focus on fostering genuine human interactions and inclusive consideration of all stakeholders.
Rationale: Conway’s law states that organizations often design systems that reflect their own communication structures. Tools alone cannot fix broken structures. It’s crucial to prioritize individuals and interactions to ensure all voices are heard and considered.
Case 2: Group Work Over Individual Tasks
Encourage collective work solutions that foster community and inclusion.
Rationale: Price’s Law suggests that a small fraction of a team often produces a significant portion of the output. Emphasizing collective work ensures that all team members contribute to creating commercial and societal value.
Case 3: Collaboration with Customers Over Negotiation
Analyze externalities and create win-win scenarios for customers and society.
Rationale: The Nash equilibrium shows the importance of mutually beneficial interactions. Ensuring that marketing practices provide real value to customers and society fosters trust and long-term relationships.
Case 4: Reacting to Change Over Following a Plan
Use Dannemiller’s formula for change to overcome internal resistance and foster a culture of continuous improvement.
Rationale: Change occurs when dissatisfaction with the current state, combined with a clear vision and concrete steps, outweighs resistance. Focusing on commitment and improving organizational culture is essential for sustainable transformation.
Conclusion
Modern marketing, despite its technological advancements, often falls short in terms of responsibility and trustworthiness. By integrating the principles of ExtrAgility into agile marketing practices, we can transform marketing into a force for good. This approach not only rebuilds trust but also ensures that marketing contributes positively to society and the environment. To embrace responsible marketing, businesses must adopt the principles of ExtrAgility. This involves rethinking traditional practices, prioritizing ethical considerations, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement. By doing so, marketing can evolve into a discipline that truly balances profit, people, and the planet.
References
Consumer’s Association of Canada CAC (n.d.). History 1947-1997. Retrieved 2024 from http://www.consumer.ca/en/history/
Conway, E. (1968). How do committees invent. Datamation, 14(4), 28-31.
Dannemiller, K., & Jacobs, R.W. (1992). Inspired by David Gleicher and originally published by Richard Beckhard.
De Solla Price, Derek J. (1963). Little Science, Big Science. New York: Columbia University Press.
Edelman. (2024). 2024 Edelman Trust Barometer methodology. Annual online survey in its 24th year. Fieldwork conducted: Nov 3 – Nov 22, 2023.
Elkington, J. (1997). The triple bottom line. Environmental management: Readings and cases, 2, 49-66.
Hormaza, T. (2022, April). Comparative website structural study and proposal of intragility, interagility, and extragility as contextual framework to guide an adaptive business agility path [MBA Project]. Université Laval, Faculté Administration des affaires (FSA) Québec, Canada.
Hormaza Dow, T. (2022, December 16). Agility and beyond in modern marketing: Responsible marketing. MBA Presentation: Responsible Marketing and ExtrAgility, Université Laval, Faculty of Business Administration.
Kotler, P., Kartajaya, H., & Setiawan, I. (2021). Marketing 5.0: Technology for humanity. John Wiley & Sons.
Larman, Craig. Agile and iterative development: a manager’s guide. Pearson Education India, 2004.
Martin, K. D., & Murphy, P. E. (2017). The role of data privacy in marketing. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 45(2), 135-155.
McGuinness, T. D., & Schank, H. (2021). Power to the public: The promise of public interest technology. Princeton University Press.
Morningstar, Helen. (1977). “The Consumers Association of Canada-The History of an Effective Organization.” Canadian Business Review, 4 (autumn), 30-33.
Nash Jr, John F. (1950). Equilibrium points in n-person games. Proceedings of the national academy of sciences, 36(1), 48-49.
Petersen, Kai, and Claes Wohlin. (2009). A comparison of issues and advantages in agile and incremental development between state of the art and an industrial case. Journal of systems and software, 82(9), 1479-1490.
Soundararajan, Shvetha. (2013). Assessing Agile Methods: Investigating Adequacy, Capability, and Effectiveness: An Objectives, Principles, Strategies Approach. Diss. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.
English 
French 
Spanish 
Chinese 
Hindi 
Korean 
Portuguese 
Czech